Catalist Omdömen 40

Zero stars if I could. Catalist Group is a complete scam that knowingly sells fake, counterfeit products while posing as only sourcing their products directly from the brands.
I bought what was supposed to be a legitimate Silpat baking mat that they were an authorized supplier for. I was the accused by Amazon and the ‘rights owner’ on the Amazon listing of selling counterfeit products. I submitted the products to the manufacturer for validation– every single one came back as COUNTERFEIT.
Throughout this process my Amazon seller account was deactivated costing my thousands in sales every week.
When I contacted Catalist Group directly for their assistance in providing documents showing where they sourced the products they sent the same scripted nonsense: “All our products are 100% authentic.” After I told them Amazon had already ruled the items counterfeit and removed them, they sent me what appeared to be an invoice from another supplier that looked like a third grader built it in Adobe. The invoice was completely redacted – when I asked that they at least show the order number and only redact the pricing they magically “couldn’t find the original.”
Do yourself a favor and never buy anything from Catalist Group, no matter what you see them selling. Total frauds.

I’ve been a client for 16 months now, I’ve watched them go from a handful of brands to over 200. They continue to add new features to the portal & improve client experience. Looking forward to many more years of continued growth.

Catalist’s process is incredibly well thought-out. Smart pricing logic that actually protect your margins. Couldn’t recommend them more highly.

Professional, reliable, and data-driven - exactly what you want from a true distribution partner.

Great company, sharp and reliable.

We own and operate a home & kitchen store in the Maine. Catalist has opened up our ability to source name brands we otherwise wouldn't be able to as a small shop, at the best dealer price as if we were a 50+ location B&M. Thank you guys, very grateful.

Have been working with Catalist for about 6 months now. Nothing but good things to say, has been a great experience all around. Our business has doubled since we started working with them. Would highly recommend.

5 stars - Found them at ASD, have done a few large high five figure PO’s so far that have went well. Great client portal that’s easy to use.

I’m a smaller fish and was worried about working with a new distributor, but Catalist made it easy. They walked me through everything. Definitely sticking with them long-term

Clear communication and the products came exactly as expected. Happy I found them.

I don't remember opening a wholesale account with Catalist Group, yet I received a welcome email from Ana stating that my account had been approved, complete with login credentials. The email initially went to my spam folder until I received a follow-up about scheduling a call.

During our phone meeting, Ana identified herself as the Head of Sales at Catalist Group. Her unprofessional presentation, combined with a heavy foreign accent that was difficult to understand, raised immediate concerns about the company's legitimacy.

Ana then explained that their Amazon ungating service would require extensive access to my Seller Central account, specifically requesting "View/Edit access for Manage Inventory, Add a Product, Manage Selling Applications, and Manage Case Log." This level of access violates Amazon's policies regarding third-party account sharing and presents significant security risks.

When I expressed my hesitation about granting account access and asked if they could provide guidance for me to handle the ungating process myself, Ana's responses were evasive. Instead of addressing my concerns directly, she focused on upselling their service (saying free of cost) and warned that if I attempted ungating independently and failed, no refunds would be provided.

Red flags:
1. Demanding extensive Amazon account access
2. Unprofessional sales approach
3. Evasive responses to legitimate security concerns
4. Threatening no-refund policy for self-service attempts

I strongly advise other Amazon sellers to exercise extreme caution when dealing with this company. Their business practices raise serious questions about legitimacy and account security.

This organization is top shelf all the way. Ana, is great to work with and you can't go wrong with the products and service.

Amazing Experience with Catalist Group!

Working with Catalist Group has been nothing but smooth and professional. Stefano and the rest of the team went above and beyond to help me with my orders. Communication was clear, support was fast, and the products arrived as promised. It’s rare to find a supplier that’s both reliable and genuinely supportive — these guys truly care about their customers.

Highly recommend Catalist Group to anyone looking for a trustworthy supplier.

Client support is the best I've encountered in the wholesale space. Extremely easy to onboard, order, and track your purchase. Definitely a leader in the space.

I deleted my review by accident. Catalist reported it and Trustpilot sent me a link requesting information for my review and I only get a 404 page.

So, to reiterate, I stand by my previous review. I have researched over 50 suppliers/distributors for FBA and there are too many red flags here. The Catalist webpage is a form to fill out and that's it. They reach out to you via email and send you a spreadsheet of their available products, with a link to the ASIN on Amazon. They explain that they only work B2B which is why their website contains no product pics, member login, about us, years in business, warehouse details, etc. Go to their website: catalistgroup.co. They have a product with an Order Button and a Learn More button. Neither of these work when clicked on. They do not provide a phone number or take you to another page as the buttons would suggest.

All of the things the dozens of legit suppliers/distributors I work with provide this information and a member login. They don't provide access to a member login page. Just use the content sent to your email to order.

Their address takes you to a shared office/virtual workspace shared by other companies: An AI search reveals: "Other Tenants at Suite 700: Interestingly, Catalist Group is not the only company associated with Suite 700 at 287 Park Avenue South. Other businesses, such as Maatimex LLC, Income Solutions, and Bottle Hill Properties (a real estate broker with a license expiring in February 2026), also list Suite 700 as their address. This suggests Suite 700 is likely a shared or coworking space managed by a provider like Le Parc or Regus, where multiple businesses can operate under the same suite number, further supporting the idea that Catalist Group’s presence may be virtual or part of a shared office arrangement.

Their FB page returns the following: 'This content isn't available right now. When this happens, it's usually because the owner only shared it with a small group of people, changed who can see it or it's been deleted.' Perhaps they had bad reviews?

I'm sure Catalist will respond again with a vehement denial. I have actually found 3 scammers from the wholesale central site, who have the same lack of transparency as Catalist. All of this review is based on facts and experience, as I am an Amazon reseller. I feel it's my duty to help resellers recognize potential red flags and make an informed decision based on research. As stated, I would NEVER purchase the MOV of $3k from a company that appears to be a ghost. There would be little to no recourse when trying to resolve issues or get a refund. Buyer beware. Do your due diligence.

The only supplier partner we use for our multiple 7-figure amazon/walmart operation. Access to 100's of brands with great pricing.

I have been working with Catalist Group for a while now and they’ve been fantastic. Great products, fair prices, and such a friendly, helpful team. Orders always arrive on time and well packed. Highly recommend!

Great customer support & great brand selection for FBA sellers.

is this a real company? website is giving me some red flags